Friday, January 23, 2026

Review: A Remembrance of Death (The Castle Drogo series) by Andrew G. Tweeddale


 

Genre: Historical fiction

Description:

This is both a sequel to the author’s earlier book, Of All Faiths & None (which won awards) and a standalone novel set between the latter days of World War I and the Fifties. It moves between Britain, California, India, Vienna and Kenya. It picks up where the first in this (short) series ends and continues a fictionalised story of the people involved with the building of Castle Drogo: its architect’s and its owner’s families and friends.

Author:

Andrew Tweeddale started his working life as a chef, went to university as a mature student to read Law, then worked in the legal world for some 30 years first as a criminal barrister, then as a solicitor before beginning his writing career. This is his second novel. This novel was short-listed for the Yeovil novel prize (a prestigious British award) which is why I picked it for review. I hope Tweeddale continues in his new career – he has a gift for telling an involved and involving story clearly at a good pace.

He splits his time between Spain and London.

Appraisal:

The families upon which the stories are based, some of the events, and all of the historical underpinnings in the book are real. Some of the characters bear the names of real people but Tweeddale assures the reader that they are, nonetheless, all entirely fictitious. I’m not sure what I think about that. However, as Tweeddale was a lawyer in a previous life I’m sure he knows what he’s doing. And you cannot libel the dead … The historical setting is rendered with a light touch as it moves forward in time. The language used never throws the reader out of its period. And it is always made clear ‘when’ we are as well as where.

This is an intricate work of fiction with a large cast of characters, who enter and leave and re-enter the book, sometimes with many years passing between appearances. Some of them, by contrast, cast a long shadow by their absence. The author maintains a godlike overview of the action, which could have been distancing but which, instead, enables the reader to keep the plot and action straight in what could otherwise have been quite a noisy novel. You may guess that, with so much going on, the book is not short. But it is consistently absorbing. The pages turn themselves. One becomes really invested in the characters.

I became increasingly delighted by the novel the more I read, and was saddened when I had to leave it, having turned the final page. There are not so many books which have this kind of power. I will definitely be investigating Of All Faiths & None.

Tweeddale says of his book “[it] is intended to take the reader through some of the darkest moments of our recent history and [show] how, as a society, we still make the same mistakes today. It does not seek to apportion blame but invites the reader to question the lessons that history teaches us.”

This is a beautifully written novel. Early in my reading of it, it began to remind me, in its tone and scope, of A Dance to the Music of Time by Anthony Powell. In his afterword the author says that he was keen to avoid it becoming too like Evelyn Waugh’s Brideshead Revisited – but there are definite resonances. There may, too, be a faint whiff of The Camomile Lawn which rises from it. If you like that sort of reading, you will enjoy this.

Buy now from:            Amazon US        Amazon UK

Format/Typo Issues:

No significant issues.

Rating: ***** Five Stars

Reviewed by: Judi Moore

Approximate word count: 115-120,000 words

No comments: