Saturday, November 1, 2014

The Broken Saint / Mike Markel

Reviewed by: BigAl

Genre: Mystery/Police Procedural

Approximate word count: 80-85,000 words

Kindle  US: YES  UK: YES  Nook: NO  Smashwords: NO  Paper: NO
Click on a YES above to go to appropriate page in Amazon, Barnes & Noble, or Smashwords store


Mike Markel teaches writing at Boise State University. In addition to the Seagate and Miner Mystery series (this is the fourth in that series) he has written eight non-fiction books on writing and numerous articles for various publications.
For more, visit the author’s website.


“Seagate and Miner investigate the murder of Maricel Salizar, a young Filipino exchange student at Central Montana State. The most obvious suspect is the boyfriend, who happens to have gang connections. And then there’s Amber, a fellow student who’s obviously incensed at Maricel for a sexual indiscretion involving Amber’s boyfriend. But the evidence keeps leading Seagate and Miner back to the professor, an LDS bishop who hosted her in his dysfunctional home. Seagate takes it in stride that the professor can’t seem to tell the truth about his relationship with the victim, but her devout partner, Ryan Miner, believes that a high-ranking fellow Mormon who violates a sacred trust deserves special punishment.”


I’d previously read Three-Way, another of the books in the Seagate and Miner mystery series. One of the things that appealed to me was the relationship between the two detectives, with Karen Seagate as the crude-talking, cynical, recovering alcoholic and Ryan Miner as the devout Mormon family man who describes himself as “a bit of a boy scout.” They’re just about polar opposites, Despite this, they have mutual respect, yet the dynamic between the two and their different styles, as ripe as it is for a lot of tense moments, rarely works out that way. Instead they tend to complement each other, with their differences and contrasting points of view making the partnership stronger.

In this installment, Ryan’s religion comes into play, at points blinding him to possible scenarios and later, when he’s not able to ignore new information they’ve uncovered, causing him to focus too much on a single suspect, to his detriment.  There’s a lesson to be learned about how our preconceptions can influence our approach to problems in a bad way. Another excellent read from Markel that keeps you guessing whodunit the whole way.


Some adult language.

Format/Typo Issues:

No significant issues

Rating: ***** Five Stars


Anonymous said...

I am in the midst of the first Seagate mystery, Big Sick Heart. Looking forward to the whole series. Great review!

KJDonovan said...

I'm reading Big Sick Heart too - thoroughly enjoying it.

Great review.

Mike Markel said...

Thanks very much, Al, for the generous review!

Unknown said...

Great review. Congratulations, Mike. The Seagate series shall rise to the top.

Laurie Boris said...

I'm really looking forward to expanding my reading repertoire and getting into this series. Great review!

Mary Smith said...

Great review. I realy like the soudn of the partnership. Have the series on my tbr list and guess I better start with Big Sick Heart which other have said they are enjoying.

Mary Smith said...

And, actually, I can spell but it's been a long day! Apologies for typos in previous comment.

BooksAndPals said...

Thanks for the comments, everyone. I know what you mean, Mary. I always see the typo as soon as I hit post and really appreciate those blogs that have a way to edit comments.

Effrosyni Moschoudi said...

Well done Mike and great review, Big Al! Makes me want to bump Mike's series in my TBR list right up! Can't wait to delve into this now :)